Weight Loss Information

Do Low Carbohydrate Diets Lead to Weight Loss Success?


So your neighbor, office mate, best friend, whoever just lost 10 pounds in only two weeks following the latest in high protein low carbohydrate diets. And now you're thinking you should give it a go -- have even started the search for high protein low carbohydrate recipes?

True, high protein low carb diets seem to be leading many people to weight loss success. Trouble is, they seemed to do it 30 years ago, too. They were the rage in the early 70s, and look where many of us are today: growing fatter with each decade.

The bottom line: Diets -- low carb diets or not -- simply don't work for the vast majority of people. If that doesn't convince you, look at some of the reasons why high protein low carbohydrate diets seem to create weight loss success stories -- but really don't.

"I'm not hungry when I eat high protein low carb diets."

Many people say they feel more satisfied eating low carbohydrate diets. And indeed, studies show protein is the most satiating nutrient. Proteins and fat (which is usually in high protein low carbohydrate foods) cause your body to release cholecystokinin, a hormone that contributes to the feeling of fullness. Some protein in meals and even snacks may help us feel more satisfied and go longer between eating. But the key word is "some." We don't need an excess of protein, or low carb diets, to get these effects. By just eating balanced meals that contain grain/starchy foods, protein foods, vegetables and/or fruits and some fat, most people can achieve the same satiety. One other important note is that hunger control with low carbohydrate diets is often the result of ketosis (when your body burns fat for fuel.) Ketosis is very unhealthy, causing nausea, headaches, fatigue, even coma.

"Results are results - I saw successful weight loss, didn't I?"

Many people do lose weight on high protein low carb diets. Instead of fat, however, they're initially losing more water than anything else -- and it quickly returns once off low carb diets. They seem to see successful weight loss, too, because low carb diets restrict many foods, resulting in eating less than usual.

The big question is: Is it really successful weight loss if it doesn't stay off? For most people, if weight loss is achieved quickly and with a restrictive method such as a diet that does not allow for individual likes and dislikes, then the lost pounds will return, along with discouragement, defeat and even more pounds than before. What's more, high protein low carb diets may also increase risk for health problems such as osteoporosis, cancer, even heart disease. A healthy intake of whole grain foods, fruits and vegetables -- often on the "avoid" list in high protein low carb diets - appears to help reduce this risk, and is the mainstay of a sensible plan to achieve weight loss success.

Create your own weight loss success story.

Despite what you hear about high protein low carb diets, there's little evidence that weight loss success is truly (permanently) achieved. What's more, disordered eating behaviors are usually reinforced by high protein low carb diets, adding to the struggles that low carbohydrate diets and other diets are supposed to solve. Stop dieting now and start living a healthy lifestyle that truly leaves you feeling good!

©2004 Green Mountain at Fox Run, Ludlow, Vermont.

Alan H. Wayler, PhD is executive director at Green Mountain at Fox Run. For over 32 years, Green Mountain has developed and refined a life-changing program exclusively for women seeking permanent strategies for healthy weight loss and health. To learn more about Green Mountain at Fox Run, visit our website at: http://www.fitwoman.com.


MORE RESOURCES:

For weight loss, cutting back on calories matters most | Gustafson
Auburn Reporter
There is no real evidence that low-carb, low-fat or high-protein diets make as big a difference as overall calorie reduction when it comes to weight loss, according to Dr. George Bray who worked on the study. "Earlier research had found that certain ...
Cut Calories For Weight Loss: ReportHuffington Post

all 6 news articles »


Weight Loss Success: Linda Goff Ditched Fad Diets And Lost 150 Pounds
Huffington Post
For almost two decades, I tried to buy my way out of obesity, spending thousands of dollars on fad diets, weight-loss shakes and pills. I learned from experience that all those drugs could do was turn a 300-pound woman into a 300-pound woman with the ...

and more »


Sydney Morning Herald (blog)

A smarter weight loss workout
Sydney Morning Herald (blog)
It's a message that anyone grappling with weight loss needs to hear, especially if trimming down is proving frustratingly slow – often a clue there's an underlying problem with insulin resistance that makes it genuinely difficult to lose weight.

and more »


PsychCentral.com

Weight Loss Programs In Church May Be More Effective
PsychCentral.com
In a new study, investigators determined that the location of the program, and the level of experience attempting a weight loss program, may influence an individual's success. In the study, published in The Journal of Black Psychology, ...
For Successful Weight Loss Don't Separate Church and WeighteMaxHealth
Weight-Loss Programmes Most Effective When Hosted In A ChurchHuffington Post UK
Weight loss program for African-American women in a church may become more ...News-Medical.net

all 6 news articles »


PR Web

Best Weight Loss Apps
Mobiles Please Blog (blog)
What better weight-loss buddy than your smartphone? It never leaves your side and it can play your favourite music to keep you motivated throughout your workout. Many apps are available to help keep you on track during your diet and exercise plan and ...
HCG Weight Loss Plan by Slim Again With Something New in ItSBWire (press release)
Diet Doc Weight Loss Introduces Artery Clearing Foods as Part of Their Overall ...PR Web (press release)
Super Bowl Temptations Derail hCG DietersSan Francisco Chronicle (press release)
DigitalJournal.com (press release) -Houston Chronicle -ReporterNews.com
all 16 news articles »


Weight Loss Impacts Leg Muscle, Strength in Knee OA
Doctors Lounge
Marius Henriksen, PT, Ph.D., of the Copenhagen University Hospital in Denmark, and colleagues used dual X-ray absorptiometry and isometric muscle strength testing to evaluate the effects of a 16-week low-energy diet-induced weight loss program on knee ...

and more »


Daily Mail

Weight-loss clinics are handing out dangerous slimming drugs with lethal side ...
Daily Mail
By Sophie Borland Patients are being put at risk by doctors selling them potentially dangerous weight-loss pills at private slimming clinics. A number of centres in England were found to be handing out drugs which could have lethal side effects, ...

and more »


SILive.com

Get extreme about weight loss with casting call on Saturday
SILive.com
By Staten Island Advance Those looking to make a lasting lifestyle change — and don't mind the entire country watching — can audition for season three of ABC's “Extreme Makeover: Weight Loss Edition” this weekend. View full sizePhoto Courtesy of ...
Casting call: 'Extreme Makeover: Weight Loss Edition'U-T San Diego
Extreme Makeover Weight Loss Michigan Casting CallUpNorthLive.com

all 3 news articles »


FDA needs stronger rules to ensure the safety of dietary supplements
Harvard Health Publications (blog)
Remember ephedra, a widely used weight-loss supplement that was banned after it was linked to deaths and adverse side effects? And solid clinical trials routinely knock down the effectiveness of dietary supplements for stopping the common cold (vitamin ...
Weight Loss Supplement May Contain Undeclared DrugNatural Standard Blog (blog)

all 25 news articles »


Key to weight loss: create a 'calorie deficiency' with workouts
The University of Alabama Crimson White
Although the answer isn't easy, the secret to weight loss is calorie deficiency – yeah, no more messy fries from Quick Grill at 2 am Cardio exercise can create a calorie deficiency by burning extra calories you can't manage to stave off through diet.


Google News

home | site map
© 2006